Table.
Studies are ordered first by year and second by alphabetical order. Only studies that reported contrasts (i.e., not only functional connectivity or correlational analyses) for psychologically healthy individuals are included here. If a study included a patient sample but still reported results for its healthy adult controls separately, it was included. Column labels: Study=study listed in references; For Participants, HYA= healthy young adult participants typically 18-30 yrs old, HOA=healthy older adults participants typically aged 60 years or older; HC=healthy adult control participants matched to patients; For Design, Goal=Goal pursued by participants to increase or decrease emotional responses, Valence=Positive or negatively valenced emotional stimuli, Tactic=Type of reappraisal used - distancing or reinterpreting, Stim Type=stimulus type, Timing of reapp cue=timing of instruction cue to reappraise relative to onset of stimulus, where early is just prior to simulus onset and late is a few seconds after stimulus onset; Amygdala?=whether modulation of amygdala was reported.
| Design |
|||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Study | Participants | Goal | Valence | Tactic | Stimulus Type | Timing of reapp cue | Amygdala? |
| Beauregard et al., 2001205 | HYA | Dec | Pos | Dist | Videos | Early* | No |
| Domes et al., 201082 | HYA | Both | Neg | Both | Photos | Late | Yes |
| Eippert et al., 200785 | HYA | Both | Neg | Both | Photos | Late | Yes |
| Erk et al., 2010a169 | HC | Dec | Neg | Dist | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Goldin et al., 200867 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Videos | Early | Yes |
| Harenski et al., 2006206 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Both | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Hayes et al., 2010140 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos | Late | Yes |
| Herwig et al., 2007207 | HYA | Dec | Both | Reint | Anticipate Photos |
Early | Yes |
| Hollmann et al., 2011208 | HYA | Dec | Pos (food) | Reint | Photos | Early | No |
| Ichikawa et al., 201183 | HYA | Both | Neg (errors) |
Reint | Task Errors | Early* | No |
| Kanske et al., 2010128 | HYA | Dec | Both | Both | Photos | Late | Yes |
| Kim et al., 200796 | HYA | Dec | Both | Reint | Photos | Early | Inc pos only |
| Kober et al., 2010119 | HYA smokers & non-smokers |
Dec | Pos (food/ cigs) |
Reint | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Koenigsburg et al., 2010200 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Dist | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Krendl et al., 2011209 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Unclear | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Kross et al., 2009113 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Memories | Late | No |
| Lang et al., 201184 | HC | Both | Neg | Dist | Scripts | Early | Inc only |
| Levesque et al., 2003210 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Dist | Videos | Early* | No |
| Mak et al., 2009211 | HYA | Dec | Both | Unclear | Photos | Early* | No |
| McRae et al., 2008212 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos | Early | Yes |
| McRae et al., 201062 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos | Early | Yes |
| McRae et al., 2012181 | Healthy aged 10-22 |
Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos | Early | No |
| McRae et al., 201215 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos of faces | Early | Yes |
| Modinos et al., 2010213 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos | Late | Yes |
| New et al., 200986 | HC | Both | Neg | Reint | Photos | Late | Yes |
| Ochsner et al., 200243 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos | Late | Yes |
| Ochsner et al., 200477 | HYA | Both | Neg | Both | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Ochnser et al., 200916 | HYA | Inc | Neg | Both | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Ohira et al., 2006116 | HYA | Dec | Both | Unclear | Photos | Early* | Yes |
| Opitz et al., 201197 | HYA & HOA | Both | Neg | Reint | Photos | Late | No |
| Phan et al., 2005115 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos | Early* | Yes |
| Pitskel et al., 201187 | Healthy aged 7-17 |
Both | Neg | Reint | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Schardt et al., in press214 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Dist | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Schulze et al., 201088 | HC | Both | Neg | Both | Photos | Late | No |
| Staudinger et al., 2009215 | HYA | Dec | Pos | Dist | Reward | Early* | No |
| Staudinger et al., 2011216 | HYA | Dec | Pos | Dist | Anticipate reward |
Early* | No |
| Urry et al., 200695 | HOA | Both | Neg | Reint | Photos | Late | Inc only |
| Urry et al., 2009217 | HOA | Both | Neg | Reint | Photos | Late | Yes |
| van Reekum et al., 200789 | HOA | Both | Neg | Reint | Photos | Late | Dec only |
| Vrticka et al., 2011218 | HYA | Dec | Both | Reint | Photos | Early* | Yes |
| Wager et al., 2008118 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Reint | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Walter et al., 2009219 | HYA | Dec | Neg | Dist | Photos | Early | Yes |
| Winecoff et al., 2010196 | HYA & HOA | Dec | Both | Dist | Photos | Late | Yes |
Notes: All studies used event-related designs (different types of trials are presented in a randomized fashion so as to estimate responses on a trial-by-trial basis) except the nine studies designated by * in the ‘Timing of reapp cue’ column, which indicates that they used a block design (trials are ‘blocked’ by type, such that many of one type appear consecutively). Also, for the stimulus type column, photo stimuli were drawn from the international affective picture system112 unless otherwise specified.
Abbreviations: Goal: Dec=Decrease, Inc=Increase, Both=Both increase and decrease conditions were used; Valence: Neg=Negative, Pos=Positive, Both=Both positive and negative stimuli were used; Strategy: Both: Both distancing and reinterpreting were used (this only applies to Ochsner, 2004) or participants were given choice of distancing or reappraising; Dist=Become more or less psychologically distant; Reint=Cognitively reinterpret; Unclear=Unclear as to what tactic was instructed.