Table 8.
Systems-contextual level: Training, organizational, client, and therapist variables
| References | n | EST | Patient | Therapist | Training | Active elements | Outcome variables | Design | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Henry, Schacht, et al. (1993) | 16 | TLDP | Adult psych. | MD and PhD | 1. Manual 2. 50 weekly seminars and supervision 3. Training case |
None | 1. Therapist A 2. Therapist S |
Pre- to postdesign; convenience sample; no f / u; no comparison group | 1. Therapist variables influenced A 2. Client variables influenced S |
| Hunter et al. (2005) | 13 | MI, group CBT | Adult subst. + COD | Mental heath counselors | 1. 2.5-hour 12-week training 2. Biweekly 3. Subset received depression training |
Interactive educational meetings (not specified) | 1. K 2. A 3. Job Sa 4. Job M |
Pre- to postdesign; convenience sample; 1-year f / u; comparison group | 1. K increased* 2. A increased* 3. Job Sa + M |
| Miller et al. (2004) | 140 | MI | Adult subst. abuse | Licensed subst. abuse profess | 1. WS 2. WSF 3. WSC 4. WSC + F 5. SGT |
Varied across training (WSF, WSC, and WSC + F) | 1. C 2. Client change talk |
Randomized; comparison group; 4-, 8-, 12-month f / u; SM | 1. All four workshops showed increase in C pre–post 2. WS group reversed gains at 4-month f / u 3. Reduction in MI-inconst. behavior |
Note. TLDP, time-limited dynamic psychotherapy; psych., psychopathology; A, adherence; S, Skill; f / u, follow-up; SM, standardized measures; MI, motivational interviewing; CBT, cognitive-behavioral therapy;subst., substance; COD, co-occurring disorders; K, knowledge; Sa, satisfaction; M, morale; WS, workshop only; WSF, workshop plus feedback; WSC, workshop plus coaching; WSC + F, workshop plus coaching and feedback; SGT, self-guided training; C, competence.
No statistical analyses completed between comparison and intervention group because of 50% staff attrition and small sample size.