Table 6.
Systems-contextual level: Training, organizational support, and therapist variables
| References | n | EST | Patient | Therapist | Training | Active elements | Outcome variables | Design | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fadden (1997) | 86 | BFT | Families with schizo. member | Nursing-level clinicians | 1. Orientation 2. Manual 3. 3-day skills workshop 4. Ten 1.5-hour supervisions 5. Ongoing monthly supervision |
Role-plays, videotaped demonstrations of sessions | 1. Number of families seen 2. Barriers to use of tx 3. Impact of BFT on work |
Convenience sample; nonrandomized; no f / u; no pre-; no control group; ICM | 1. 70% reported using BFT 2. Mean families seen = 1.7 3. 66% reported difficult to use 4. Therapists in the comm. or where more staff members were trained in BFT saw more families 5. Little attitude change |
| Henggeler, Chapman, et al. (2008) | 432 | CM | Subst. abuse in adol. | Public sector clinicians | 1. Manual 2. 1-day didactic and experiential workshop |
Experiential role-plays | 1. Adop 2. A 3. Org* |
Convenience sample; nonrandomized; 6-month f / u; no control group; ICM + SM | 1. 58% reported use 2. Pract. variables predicted adop 3. Pract. and org. variables predicted A |
| Maunder et al. (2008) | 25 | CBT | Adult and youth in PC | MDs | 1. 3- to 4-hour workshop 2. Manual 3. Four 1.5-hour case discussions |
Case discussion groups | 1. K 2. Self-reported use 3. Att and Sa |
Convenience sample; nonrandomized; no f / u; no control group; ICM + SM | 1. High Sa 2. Increased K 3. Increased use |
| Morganstern et al. (2001) | 29 | CBT | Adult subst. abuse | Subst. abuse counselors | 1. 100 hours training (35-hour didactic training and feedback, supervision, and manual) | Role-plays and feedback | 1. Rated A 2. Rated S 3. Att and Sa |
Randomized; comparison group; no f / u; ICM and SM | 1. High Sa 2. High Att toward CBT 3. Proficient A & S |
| Siqueland et al. (2000) | 62 | CT, DP, DC | Adult subst. abuse | Subst. abuse counselors | 1. Manual 2. Four 2-day workshops 3. Unspecified supervision |
Role-plays | 1. Rated A 2. Rated C |
Convenience sample; nonrandomized; no f / u; no control group; ICM and SM | 1. In CT general experience and specific experience in CT predicted C |
Note. BFT, behavioral family therapy; schizo., schizophrenia; tx, treatment; f / u, follow-up; ICM, investigator-created measures; CM, contingency management; subst., substance; adol., adolescent; Adop, adoption; A, adherence; Org, organizational variables; SM, standardized measures; CBT, cognitive-behavioral therapy; PC, primary care; MDs, physicians; K, knowledge; Att, attitudes; Sa, satisfaction; S, skill; C, competence; CT, cognitive therapy; DP, dynamic therapy; DC, drug counseling.
not included as an outcome variable, but measured organizational characteristics as predictors.